- Ion Irradiation for High Fidelity Simulation of High Dose Neutron Irradiation

Principal Investigator
Name:
Todd Allen
Email:
[email protected]
Phone:
(208) 526-6918
Team Members:
Name: Institution: Expertise: Status:
J Guerrier
M Liu
S Thomas-Podowitz
Emmanuelle Marquis University of Michigan radiation damage, APT Faculty
Brian Wirth University of California-Berkeley nuclear fuels, radiation damage, structural materials, radiation resistant materials Faculty
Steven Zinkle University of Tennessee-Knoxville Characterization of HT9/T91 to determine the role of He in cavity evolution Faculty
Experiment Details:
Experiment Title:
Ion Irradiation for High Fidelity Simulation of High Dose Neutron Irradiation)
Work Description:
This proposal is part of a DOE-NE funded program to simulate the microstructure of neutron irradiated alloys using ion irradiation. As part of this funded program, samples of the alloys of interest (HT-9, T91, 800H) will be irradiated using heavy ions to parallel irradiations in the BOR-60 fast reactor in Russia. Traditionally, research to understand radiation-induced changes in materials is conducted via radiation effects experiments in nuclear test reactors (both fast and thermal), followed by a comprehensive post- irradiation examination plan. This is a very time-consuming process because of the low damage rates in even the highest flux test reactors preventing radiation damage research from "getting ahead" of problems discovered during operation. In addition, the dearth of available test reactors worldwide and the high cost of research on activated materials place additional constraints on this approach. All of these constraints have compromised the rate of advancement of our understanding of neutron irradiation effects at high doses. Our solution is to use self-ion irradiation to irradiate materials at high dose rates and to very high doses required for concepts such as the sodium fast reactor (SFR), lead fast reactor (LFR), molten salt reactor (MSR) and the traveling wave reactor (TWR). Dose rates (typically 10-3 to 10-4 dpa/s) using self-ions are much higher than under neutron irradiation (10-7 to 10-8 dpa/s), which means that the target, end-of-life doses for reactors such as SFRs (hundreds of dpa), can be reached in days instead of years. The challenge is to determine the ion irradiation conditions that produce microstructures relevant to reactor core conditions. Thus, the objective of this proposal is to quantitatively assess the capability of ion irradiation to emulate reactor irradiation for several exposure conditions, and to demonstrate the capability to predict the evolution of microstructure and properties of structural materials in-reactor and at high doses, using ion irradiation as a surrogate for reactor irradiations. This proposal requests support using heavy ions to irradiate two alloys, T91 and HT9, to 9 combinations of temperature and total irradiation dose. Both alloys would be irradiated simultaneously at each temperature/dose combination. Additionally, alloy 800H would need to be irradiated to three doses at 360°C. Thus, 12 total irradiations requiring 950 dpa in total or 19 days of support are required. Ion irradiations will be conducted in dual-beam mode using a defocused self-ion beam and a raster-scanned He beam in the multi-beam chamber (MBC) at the Michigan Ion Beam Laboratory (MIBL) at the University of Michigan. Samples will be irradiated with 5 MeV Fe++ ions in a direction normal to the surface, with co-implantation of He at 60° (angle) to the surface normal over the depth range 300 - 1000 nm achieved by the pre- programmed rotation of a degrader foil in front of the sample. Target He concentrations will be in the range 0.1 to 0.2 appm He/dpa for ferritic- martensitic alloys, and 0.5 - 1.0 appm He/dpa for alloy 800H. For these ion irradiations, the damage rate will be maintained between 5 x 10-4 dpa/s and 1 x 10-3 dpa/s. Irradiations will be conducted at elevated temperature relative to that in-reactor to compensate for effect of a higher damage rate on the irradiated microstructure.
Project Summary
The promise for developing new, advanced nuclear reactor concepts that significantly improve on commercial nuclear power reactors, and the extension of life of existing light water nuclear reactors rests heavily on understanding how neutron irradiation can degrade the properties of materials that serve as the structural components in reactor cores. In high-dose fission reactor concepts such as the sodium fast reactor (SFR), lead fast reactor (LFR), molten salt reactor (MSR) and the traveling wave reactor (TWR), structural materials must survive up to or over 200 dpa of damage at temperatures in excess of 400°C. A promising solution to achieving such high doses in a rapid and economical manner is ion irradiation. Challenges to the implementation of ion irradiation as a surrogate for neutron irradiation include accounting for rate effects, small irradiation volumes, accounting for transmutation and the lack of data to establish the equivalence of the resulting microstructures. Addressing these challenges constitutes the main focus of this program. This program consists of four major elements, or thrusts: 1) establishment of the capability to conduct dual- and triple- ion irradiations that capture the key elements of the BOR-60 reactor neutron spectrum and development of both ion and reactor irradiation programs, 2) characterization (both experimental and computational) of the evolution of the irradiated microstructure over a wide dose range relevant to fast and thermal reactors, and 3) establishment of the microstructure - property relationship for irradiated materials, and 4) engagement the worldwide radiation effects community through the creation of workshops and working groups to address ion irradiation techniques, irradiated sample preparation and the analysis of microstructure defects. Key elements of the program are A) both ion and neutron irradiation will be performed on the same alloys/heats, B) both damage and transmutation effects will be incorporated seamlessly into the irradiations, and C) the meshing of experiment and modeling efforts will occur across all length scales and all aspects of the program. The program will focus on a set of alloys chosen because: 1) they represent potential candidate alloys for fast reactors (T91 and HT9) and as can be considered as candidate replacement alloys for LWRs at high doses (800H). Importantly, complementary neutron irradiation data exists for several of these alloy heats. Finally, they are amenable to inclusion in a fast reactor irradiation campaign designed to produce a substantive set of data set to allow for a comprehensive comparison of ion and neutron irradiation effects. This project will demonstrate the capability to evaluate the behavior of reactor materials at high irradiation doses. Key to this effort is benchmarking of the microstructures formed under ion irradiation and neutron irradiation by a combined experimental and analytical approach. This RTE will generate valuable data on the microstructure of candidate alloys exposed using ion irradiation for comparison against that from neutron irradiation. The final product will provide a path and a methodology for qualifying materials for service at very high doses.
Relevance
The mission of the DOE Office of Nuclear Energy is to advance nuclear power to meet the nation's energy, environmental, and national security needs. This RTE focuses on the generation of data on high dose ion irradiation for the purpose of benchmarking it against neutron irradiation to establish it as a viable technique for rapidly advancing the development of materials for advanced reactor concepts and core structural components in life-extended LWRs. The focus on candidate alloys T91 and HT9 in this RTE addresses the goal of the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) program to conduct R&D on advanced reactor concepts. Since these alloys are also considered for fuel cladding and duct components, the project also supports the mission of the Fuel Cycle Research and Development (FCRD) program to conduct R&D to develop sustainable fuel cycles. The inclusion of candidate core structural alloy 800H supports the mission of the Light Water Reactor Sustainability (LWRS) program of conducting R&D to develop the scientific basis for understanding and predicting long-term environmental degradation behavior of material in nuclear power plants. Finally, the inclusion of collaborators from England, Japan and Australia, and a collaborative benchmarking effort led by the IAEA supports the mission of the Office of International Nuclear Energy Policy and Cooperation (INEPC) to encourage international participation in the development of nuclear energy.